A visitor arrives at the practice-notes hub of the fictional music school Reed & Meter. Some visitors already know they want notes for beginners, for exam pieces, or for practicing at home. Others need a short explanation of what this collection is before they choose a path. In this example, the hub opens with a long studio story. The tiles for those three collections sit farther down, below what a first look on a phone can show.
Reed & Meter is a teaching example, not a test result. The useful question is what visitors should encounter first on this hub: orientation, destinations, or a concise combination.
“Lead with story” and “lead with the grid” are this guide’s terms for the opening choice. Use the questions below to propose an opening, not to conclude that one layout performs better. A site can use both, on different hubs, and the marketer decides. No source supplied for this guide tests a story-first opening against a grid-first opening, including on non-retail hubs.
Use these questions as a way to think, not as a score:
- What must the visitor understand before choosing a path?
- What can a clear destination label communicate on its own?
- Is the introductory material helping the choice, or postponing it?
Story, Grid, or a Short Orientation First
A story-led opening can help when a visitor needs context before the tiles make sense. A destination-led opening can help when the labels already name the paths people came for. A third option is a short orientation, then the tiles, so the first look explains the collection without hiding the way in.
On Reed & Meter’s practice-notes hub, “Beginner practice,” “Exam pieces,” and “Practice at home” may already be clear enough to lead. A long studio story that delays those tiles postpones the choice. A two-sentence explanation of what the notes are for, followed by the same tiles, is a mix, not a compromise that has to be justified by a study.
This guide stops at the opening. How a retail category orients a shopper is already covered in Product Category Page Best Practices. The listing grid itself, including cards, filters, and empty filter results, belongs in Product Listing Page Best Practices. Non-retail hubs, such as a practice-notes collection or a resources section, are in scope here.
If the question is what a homepage should do, lead as a story or as a directory of routes, use Homepage as a Story, or as a Directory?. That is a homepage decision, not a hub-opening decision.
Paste the hub address into Online Website Previewer and press Preview. That address opens in all three frames: phone 390 by 844, tablet 820 by 1180, and desktop 1920 by 1080 CSS pixels. The previewer is a visual check of layout in your current browser, not a test of a particular device. A desktop opening can show both the introduction and the tiles, while a phone opening may show only the introduction. Look at what a first view can show at each width. If the destinations are only visible after a long story, say so.
Where the Sources Disagree
In 2018 research across 49 ecommerce sites, Nielsen Norman Group described category pages as midlevel pages that introduce product groupings, and noted that, compared with the past, fewer sites provided traditional category pages as interim pages. The most successful mergers of category and listing pages, in that research, highlighted available subcategories separately from other filters.
Baymard’s 2026 public writing on ecommerce category pages describes a category page as a navigational hub that organizes a section of a catalog and helps shoppers find their way to the right subcategory or product type, and says the page’s job is navigation, not browsing.
Those are different accounts of how category pages are changing and what they are for. They do not settle whether a marketing hub should open with a story. Do not flatten them into “category pages are obsolete.” Use them as a reminder that the opening should help a visitor decide where to go next.
If the issue is what draws the eye first on the hub, use How to Review a Website’s Visual Hierarchy.
Send a Lead-With-Story, Lead-With-the-Grid, or Mix Note
A useful note might say: “At [address], I checked the phone, tablet, and desktop previews at 390 by 844, 820 by 1180, and 1920 by 1080 CSS pixels, respectively. In the phone preview, the practice-notes hub opens with a long studio story, and the tiles for beginner practice, exam pieces, and practice at home are not in the first look. A visitor who already knows which collection they want has to scroll past the story. Please try a short orientation, then the tiles, unless there is a reason this hub must lead with the longer story. This is an opening suggestion, not a finding that one pattern performs better.”
For how to phrase the note, see How to Give Useful Feedback on a Website Design.



