The fictional Wren Workshop is deciding how to introduce its evening furniture-making classes on the homepage. One version shows a still photograph of a finished stool. A second version plays a short clip of the stool being assembled. A third version leads with a clear invitation and the next step, and uses no image at all.
Choose a still image, motion, or a text-led hero with no image according to what a first-time visitor needs to understand. For Wren Workshop, ask whether the opening explains the class offer and gives visitors a way to see dates.
The workshop example is fictional, not a test result.
Choose the Information Before the Format
Nielsen Norman Group’s 2024 homepage principles say the homepage should communicate the unique value proposition clearly, usually through a descriptive tagline and compelling content in the hero space. They also advise avoiding purely decorative or unhelpful graphics, as people tend to skip over them. The homepage is the most valuable real estate on the site, so every image should serve a purpose and add value.
That is the first question, before you choose still or motion. What must a first-time visitor understand, and what would a large opening visual add? The first-view content itself, including the offer and a next step, is covered in What Belongs Above the Fold on Mobile?. This guide is only about the media treatment of that opening.
Use this matrix as a way to think, not as a score.
| Question | Still image | Motion | Text-led, no image |
|---|---|---|---|
| What information would this add? | A real object, place, or context the visitor needs to see | A process or change that a still frame cannot show | A clear offer and next step, without a large visual |
| When is this a useful choice? | When visitors need a picture of the work | When visitors need to see the process or change | When the words already explain the offer and next step |
Still Images and Motion Each Need a Reason
Sources do not fully agree about decorative photography, and both still have a useful point.
Jakob Nielsen, in 2010 research last reviewed in 2026, found that some types of pictures are completely ignored, typically big feel-good images that are purely decorative, while informative photos of products and real people get more scrutiny. Baymard’s 2021 ecommerce homepage research observed that sites relying on stock photography or bland cut-out imagery underperformed in their testing, and that sites with inspiring, custom photography drew positive remarks, with a caution that it can be possible to go too far with a bespoke look.
Read those together this way: both favor imagery that shows the real product or context over a generic mood image. They do not settle whether a beautiful photograph, on its own, is enough of a reason to use a hero image.
If the opening is motion, ask what the movement shows that a still would not. A process clip of the Wren stool being assembled can earn its place. A decorative loop that delays the offer cannot. How a video is allowed to start, and how to review captions and controls, belongs in How to Review Video and Autoplay on a Marketing Page. If it makes sound, Sound On by Default is the decision guide.
If the “hero” is actually several rotating items, use Homepage Carousels: Keep, Fix, or Drop?.
Consider a Text-Led Hero
A text-led opening with no image is a legitimate third option. That is this guide’s reasoning, not a research finding that text wins. The sources above are about informative versus generic imagery, and about what a homepage opening should explain. They do not test a hero that is only a value proposition and a next step.
If a photograph would be generic, or a video would delay the offer, leading with the words can be the clearer choice. The Wren Workshop invitation, “Evening classes in furniture making, with a stool you take home,” plus a way to see dates, may do more than a mood image of a workshop.
Judge the Opening and What Follows
Nielsen Norman Group has observed that large hero graphics or videos often push important content below the fold, out of immediate view, and offer no additional cues to invite people to scroll. Their 2024 principles also say to avoid autoplaying videos. Visitors typically do not expect, or appreciate, being immediately greeted with loud, moving content, and an auto-starting video can be so intrusive that it hampers someone’s ability to engage with any other page content. In one example from the 2024 principles, a manufacturer’s homepage showed a video that took several seconds to load, and the first seconds of the page had no visible content. Treat that as one case, not a typical duration.
If words sit on a still photograph, use How to Keep Text Readable Over Website Photos for the contrast and placement check.
Paste the page address into Online Website Previewer and press Preview. Compare the first view at 390 by 844, 820 by 1180, and 1920 by 1080 CSS pixels, the tool’s phone, tablet, and desktop sizes. A picture that works at the desktop width may crop out the product on a phone, or push the offer and the next step out of the first view. That is a layout check. It is not a test of how video plays in every browser.
A useful note might say: “On the Wren Workshop homepage at [address], in the 390 by 844 preview, the class offer is not visible until I scroll. Please compare a still of a finished stool, or a text-led opening with the invitation and a way to see dates, so the first view already explains the offer.”



