November 15, 2026

Illustration, Photography, or Both: Pick a Default

Choose photography, illustration, or both as a sitewide default, give each type a job, and keep each type consistent with itself. The brand pick is a matter of taste, not a finding that one medium performs better.

A chrome stand holding a line drawing of a kiln beside a photograph of a pink-glazed mug, with a blue pencil and a camera lens in front, on an orange background.
In this guide

The fictional ceramics studio Field & Kiln is writing an image brief. Finished mugs will be shown in photographs. A firing schedule will be explained with a simple drawing. Nobody has decided what to use on the class page: a photo of the Saturday group, a drawing of the making process, or both.

Pick a default — photography, illustration, or both — give each type a job, and keep each type consistent with itself. Choose a default that suits your brand and what the images need to communicate. This guide does not establish that either medium performs better overall. No study in this research compared photography and illustration on marketing sites for comprehension, trust, or recall. When both mediums could do the job, the brand pick itself is a matter of taste.

Use the image’s job to guide the choice:

  • When the job is to show something actual and specific, such as a mug, a place, or a person, photography is often the clearer fit.
  • When the job is to explain a process or a concept, illustration is often the clearer fit.
  • When the job is only to set a tone, either medium can work, and consistency matters more than the pick.

Those typical jobs follow published design guidance. They are not exclusive rules, and you can choose otherwise if you do it on purpose.

Give Each Type a Job

Google’s Material Design imagery guidance says images should be selected “for their ability to express your message and reflect your product’s style,” and that whether you use user-generated photography, professional photography, or different styles of illustration, they should all “lend a look and feel that reflects your product.” Google no longer maintains Material 2, so treat this as design guidance, not a current standard.

The GOV.UK Design System gives a similar split for its own services: use photography when it is important to show a lifelike representation of something, not to represent abstract concepts, and use illustrations to show a simplified image of something complex. That is GOV.UK’s house guidance, not a general law.

Whether a photograph is generic or specific is a separate question, covered in When Stock Photos Don’t Earn Their Place.

Keep Each Type Consistent With Itself

Google’s Material Design imagery guidance says images “should be related to one another by sharing a common function, style, and intention.” This guide’s reading is that photographs should share a lighting and framing style, and illustrations a palette, level of detail, and line style.

GOV.UK asks for the same kind of consistency within illustrations: consistent colors, line widths, and border radiuses across the set.

The default can still be “both.” This guide’s extension is that the consistency requirement still applies within each type: photographs should look like one photographic set, and illustrations should look like one drawn set, even when they appear on the same page.

On Field & Kiln’s class page, a documentary photo of the kiln can sit beside a simple diagram of the making steps, if the photographs share a lighting style and the diagrams share a line weight. A new, highly detailed illustrated character that does not match the diagrams would be the thing to question.

If the catalog uses photography, the style of those product photos is covered in How Consistent Is Your Product Photography Across the Catalog?. Words on a still image are covered in How to Keep Text Readable Over Website Photos. Images on a dark surface are covered in How to Review Your Website’s Dark Mode.

Send the Default and the Exceptions

Write a short policy the team can reuse, then list mismatches to align and any exceptions you recommend keeping. You can also send a note about one mismatched set before a sitewide default is agreed.

A useful note might say: “Please make photography the default for Field & Kiln’s products, studio, and people, and use a single simple line-illustration style for processes such as the firing schedule. On the class page at [address], the Saturday group photo and the process diagram can both stay if the diagram is redrawn to match the other process drawings. Please keep the instructor portrait consistent with the existing photographs, rather than adding a third illustration style.”

The Field & Kiln brief is a teaching example, not a test result, and not evidence that photography is the better default.