The fictional ceramics studio Field & Kiln puts three small symbols beside each class: a clock-like mark, a flame, and a stack of bowls. One teammate reads them as duration, difficulty, and class size. Another reads the flame as “uses the kiln.” A visitor who has not learned the set has to guess.
Use visible words as the sitewide default, either alone or beside an icon. Keep the icon when it adds something useful. Otherwise, use words alone. Treat any unlabeled icon as an exception that still has to be understood at a glance, without hovering.
Use these questions as a way to think:
- Is the meaning or action specific, or easy to confuse with a nearby control?
- Can you name that meaning or action without already knowing the set?
- Is an icon-only treatment being kept for a stated reason, or only to save space?
Use Words Alone or Beside an Icon
Two other sources point the same way. Susan Wiedenbeck of Dalhousie University compared an application whose buttons had text labels, icons, or both in a 1999 study in Behaviour & Information Technology. For novice users in the first session, performance was best with label-only and icon-plus-label buttons and much poorer with icon-only buttons, which approached the others by the second session, and perceived ease of use was best for icon plus label. It tested one application, and the abstract gives no sample size. Google’s Material 3 navigation bar guidance says “All navigation items require a label text,” and calls the label “another way for people to understand an icon’s meaning.” Nielsen Norman Group (2014) adds that icon labels should be visible at all times, without any interaction from the user, and that it is often safer to include a label even on a standard icon.
The same guidance warns against relying on hover to reveal text labels. Hover increases the work, and it does not translate well on touch devices. In their example, a desktop site hid labels until hover, while the mobile site showed labels beside the icons.
Online Website Previewer changes the width of a page. It does not copy touch input, so it cannot settle whether a hover label is missing on a phone. Check hover and tap behavior in a real browser or on a real phone. Phone Preview vs Real Phone: What to Check covers that distinction.
Conventions Are Not a Free Pass
Nielsen Norman Group also names some icons as conventions. A 2021 article on consistency mentions the shopping-cart icon for items you plan to purchase, and a magnifier-glass icon for search. It does not give a list of icons that may go unlabeled. The 2014 advice to include a visible label still stands.
Take those together, rather than inventing an exemption list. A cart or a search magnifier may be more widely recognized than Field & Kiln’s flame. It is still safer to show a word next to them, and it is a problem when a custom mark — “Book a class,” “difficulty,” “class size” — is left to stand on its own.
The same 2021 article also warns that consistency can cost distinguishability. Its example is Google’s Mail, Calendar, and Drive icons, which were updated to use the same colors and, at a small size, can be hard to tell apart. If Field & Kiln draws duration, difficulty, and class size as similar bowl outlines in the same glaze color, labeling them is not only about meaning. It is also about telling them apart.
The menu icon, and whether it should be labeled “Menu,” is already covered in How to Review a Mobile Menu. How you describe a functional image for people who cannot see it is covered in How to Write Alt Text for Images. This guide is the sitewide label policy, not a second pass on those controls.
A visual review also cannot settle contrast or accessible names. WCAG 2.2 Success Criterion 1.4.11, at Level AA, asks for 3:1 contrast for stand-alone icons when they are needed to understand the content. Success Criterion 2.5.3, at Level A, asks that a control’s accessible name contain the text that is presented visually. Flag a concern, and ask a specialist or a developer to check it. Do not treat the preview as an accessibility audit.
Send the Label or Exception Note
If a sitewide label policy is already agreed, write it first, then list the icons that are allowed to stand without a visible word, and why. If it is not, start with the unlabeled icons you saw on this page.
A useful note might say: “Please add a visible text label next to every icon in the Field & Kiln header and class cards, including Book a class, not only the cart. At [address], in the 390 by 844 phone preview, the flame and bowl marks sit without labels, and I cannot tell difficulty from class size. If any icon is meant to stay unlabeled, please confirm that a first-time visitor can name the meaning or action at a glance, without hovering.”
The Field & Kiln symbols are a teaching example, not a test result.



